Beginning with a spluttering series of projected clips that include a lamb being softly cradled while thick, black blood drains from its throat; a hand, jolting, as iron nails are struck into its palm; and the body of a young boy stirring from rest in a morgue, Persona, from writer-director Ingmar Bergman, soon settles into a story about an actress who has decided that she no longer wishes to speak. Played by Liv Ullmann, this mute performer, named Elisabet, is assigned a nurse of similar age to look after her and perhaps help coax back her voice. Bibi Andersson's Alma shrinks ever so slightly when given the assignment, conscious perhaps of a disparity in social standing between the two women. What could they have in common? Packed off to a cottage by the sea, as a way of disconnecting with a modern world teeming with upsetting imagery, the pair settle into a pleasant, paperback-reading domesticity.
Alma happily chats away, filling the silence between the pair and remarking that, for the first time she can recall, she feels like she's actually being listened to. This isn't a back-and-forth though. Elisabet's only contribution is a silent smile. This lack of conversational impediment is enough to encourage Alma to really plumb the depths of her psyche, summoning up memories that are, for her, deeply rooted in shame. A drunken Alma details a casual sexual experience between herself, a sunbathing woman she found herself in awe of, and a pair of young boys who had been spying on them. This confession appears, thanks to Elisabet's stillness, to have fallen on sympathetic or even understanding ears. A gentle grin and no words of judgement regarding this escapade or the calculated cover-up revealed by Alma - she seduced her fiancé that evening to ensure that no objections would be raised when she later required an abortion - leaves the nurse feeling understood in a way that she isn't used to. This is an intimacy she hasn't otherwise experienced.
This happiness doesn't last though. The following day, while out driving to the nearest post office, Alma lets her curiosity get the better of her: opening an unsealed envelope and reading a letter written by Elisabet that makes her feel small and used. The mocking tone of the correspondence leaves Alma with the impression that Elisabet sees her as a silly little subject to be studied rather than, say, the beloved companion of a worldly actress. The typed text is candid and dismissive, Alma's very personal scandal transmuted into flat, mocking gossip to be transmitted to a sneering outsider. Naturally, Alma and Elisabet's relationships disintegrates into recrimination and even threats of beauty-altering violence. Bergman and cinematographer Sven Nykvist photograph their subjects in sculpted close-ups, where creeping light accentuates every tiny hair covering the human body. The two women's faces are seen to overlap in packed compositions and, eventually, they converge into one, asymmetrical portrait. As the film progresses, and third-parties interact with them interchangeably, it actually becomes less and less clear that these women even are two, distinct people.
Alma's revenge on her mute charge is a repeated dressing down that details Elisabet's failures as a mother. The decision for Elisabet to even be a parent is contextualised by Alma as a kind of stubborn response to a boorish dinner guest who questioned if the actress could truly see herself as successful if she hadn't bore a child. The nurse intuits or perhaps even recalls the failed terminations that preceded the birth of Elisabet's estranged son. This is a child who, very obviously, was not wanted yet still persists in adoring a mother that denies him even the most basic of connection. With this in mind, it's difficult then not to recall the sickly, gangly-looking child who seemed to rise from a cold mortuary table then press himself against a blurred image of a woman at the beginning of Persona. Surely no accident as well that the boys that Alma spontaneously slept with were described as not just shy but physically uncomfortable and then how similarly Bergman's film portrays this discarded, undead child. If these women are two halves of the same whole, is Elisabet's maternal disgust rooted in the ignoble conception proposed by Alma? Has their biggest shame taken on physical life? Or do the similarities in experience simply speak to some underlining horror related to motherhood? Persona is threaded with dead ends and deliberate contradiction but all routes to understanding do at least seem to be premised on the acknowledgement that this a symbiotic relationship between an unsophisticated chatterbox and the ravenous mute who feeds upon her.




.jpg)





